Online dating has become so much easier than ever before. There are now millions singles using dating apps and sites, and thousands of success stories.
Online dating starts with selecting the right dating site. This article will focus on Match and eHarmony.
Both Match and eHarmony offer premium dating services. Both have been around for more than two decades. They are both designed for serious relationships and both charge a fee to send and receive messages. It is important to choose the right one for you.
This review will compare and contrast the two online dating websites to help you make an informed decision. I will be comparing the quality of each site’s profiles, potential matches, and quality of conversation to determine if they are worth upgrading. I will end my review by suggesting some other options.
Ready? Let’s get started.
Match Vs EHarmony
| Matchmaking: The Pros | Pros of eHarmony |
|---|---|
| Trustworthy established dating site | The best way to build meaningful relationships |
| Millions of members | Responsible for over 600,000 marriages |
| Excellent user layout | Amazing matchmaking system |
| The Cons of Match | Cons of eHarmony |
|---|---|
| Your messages can’t be read by non-members | There are not many people over 40. |
Match vs eHarmony: Which site has better profiles?
Match
Match.com has the highest quality profiles and is considered one of the most popular dating sites. There are several reasons why this is so. Match requires that everyone who creates an Account complete their profile builder. This tool is unique to Match and allows users to start their dating profiles.
It’s perfect for those who don’t know what to put on their online dating profile. It walks you through a step by step process that includes creating an “About Me” paragraph and filling out a few details about your self. This ensures that every Match profile has at least basic information.
Match also allows users to upload up to 26 photos. Although most users won’t upload that many photos, it gives you plenty of room to fill out your profile.
Thirdly, Match users are most likely looking for serious relationships and will take the time to make their profile stand out.
Match also adds a compatibility score to each profile. This is based upon how much you share in common. This allows you to decide if you’re a match and you should start talking.
Match is a little lacking in one thing: it’s completely free to create an account, browse other profiles, and even make a purchase. There are a lot of free profiles, but they often lack detail. It also means that there may be fake profiles.
eHarmony
eHarmony is a premium dating website that targets people who are searching for long-term relationships. It is responsible for more than 600,000 marriages. It takes seriously, and its users have taken it as such.
It is therefore natural to expect that eHarmony’s profiles are of high quality. This is a good thing.
Everybody who signs up for eHarmony must take a long personality test and complete a questionnaire. All answers given are displayed on the profile.
Moreover, although it is not mandatory to add something to your ‘About Me section, many people sign up for eHarmony to get a better idea of who they really are and what they’re searching for.
If you’re not sure if the two of them are compatible, eHarmony has a ‘compatibility tab’ to each profile that gives you a percentage of your personality, values, and attitude.
This tab also shows each person:
- Romance
- Exclusion
- Athleticism
- Accommodation
- Affection
- Intellect
- Altruism
- Agreeableness
- Extraversion
- Social values
- Religious values
- Relationship values
- Intimacy in the physical
- Conscientiousness
- Emotional intimacy
Some profiles may be more detailed than others. Each person decides how much information they want to include in their profile. eHarmony is a premium dating website that’s primarily used by people who want to settle down and possibly have children with someone. Most profiles provide enough information to allow you to decide if you should chat.
eHarmony also offers help to everyone with their profile which improves the quality.
There are virtually no fake profiles on eHarmony.
The Winner:
Match and eHarmony almost have the same profile quality, but eHarmony is just slightly ahead.
Why?
It is more common for Match.COM to have fake profiles than eHarmony. This can be frustrating. Match.COM is still viewed as a dating site that can be used for short-term and long-term relationships. This means that you’ll find many free profiles that haven’t taken the time or effort to complete their profiles.
Although profiles on eHarmony don’t always provide a lot of detail, they still give you a good idea about the person. The compatibility tab is a great bonus.
Match vs eHarmony: Which site offers better quality matches?
Match.com
Match allows you to adjust your search criteria to find compatible matches. You can adjust criteria like age and location as well as more detailed criteria like someone’s personal and professional life, looks, background and values.
You can also modify your criteria based on their last login and what you are looking for.
This will definitely increase the quality of your matches. Match has a matchmaking service that matches you with compatible people based on your preferences. Match does not have this feature, unlike many premium dating sites. You don’t have to complete a questionnaire or personality test when you create an account. The site also doesn’t suggest matches for you. Although it does offer a list of suggestions, it is not the same.
eHarmony
eHarmony differs from Match in that it has a matchmaking system which curates matches that are specifically tailored to you.
The process works as follows: You must complete a lengthy personality test and a compatibility quiz before you create an account. These tests are meant to help you discover more about yourself, your interests, your values, and your goals.
eHarmony uses your answers to create an algorithm. Once your profile is created, it displays a percentage for each profile that you visit. This allows you to see how compatible you are. This will allow you to see if you should have a conversation.
Indeed, eHarmony is proud of the match quality and I must admit that they are very accurate.
The Winner:
eHarmony’s compatibility tab displays how compatible you think you are with another person. eHarmony’s track record in creating happy couples is proof that it can be trusted to accurately calculate your compatibility score.
Match is a site that allows you to determine how compatible you are with another person. Most people only need to look at the information that a person has posted to their profile. This can sometimes be very minimal.
Match has more advanced search filters than eHarmony, but eHarmony only offers a basic search function. You can’t modify your matches based on age or location.
Overall though, eHarmony is just a shade behind when it comes to quality matches.
Match vs eHarmony: The Quality of Conversation
Match.com
Match is primarily aimed at long-term relationships. You would expect that there is a high level of quality conversation. It can also be very inconsistent.
Many people are reluctant to send a message, so instead they will send you a smile or a like. Worse, Match has a lot free profiles. You might also notice that you get a lot number of likes. If they have a free profile, they will not be able reply to your message.
The quality of the conversation is largely determined by the person. Match is full of smart, funny, intelligent, talkative singles. They will be willing to make an effort to have a conversation, especially if they are a paid member.
eHarmony
Much like Match, eHarmony’s quality conversation is often determined by whether the person who messages you is a paid or free user.
But there’s one key difference that separates the two dating websites. Match allows free members to send ‘likes’, but not personal messages. Free members on eHarmony can ask five automated questions and can see your responses to each one.
After you’ve answered the five questions, you must upgrade your account to be able to chat properly with the other member.
This increases the quality of the conversation as it gives those who don’t know what to say in an opening messages the chance to start things off well. The automated questions have been prepared by eHarmony and help you to get to know one another.
Other than that, eHarmony has a similar membership profile to Match. This means that the quality and content of each subsequent conversation is determined by the individual. Nevertheless, paid members can rest assured that they will make an effort to have a productive conversation.
The Winner:
eHarmony is a better choice because they have automated questions. They are available to both paid and free members. They’re great icebreakers and don’t require you to answer the boring, uninspiring “hey, how’s it going?” intro. Match is not exempt from this.
Match vs eHarmony: Which site offers more upgrade value?
Match
Match offers three subscription options:
- 1 month – $35 per month
- 3 months – $25 per month
- 6 months – $15 per month
Register for an account now and you’re free to sign up. You can browse other profiles, send smiles and likes to them, but you cannot access any special features. You can’t send and receive messages.
Match’s upgrade is a great value because you can send messages. You also get access to other features like video dates, pre-prepared drinks, and Boost (which increases your profile’s visibility for an hour), aswell as ‘Match Me’, which places you at the top on another member’s suggestions list.
These are all useful features that, together with the affordable price and the ability to send messages, increase Match’s upgrade value.
eHarmony
eHarmony offers 3 subscription options:
- 6 months – $35 per month
- 12 months – $15 per month
- 24 months – $12 per month
Unless you upgrade your account, you are limited to what you can do on eHarmony. Although you can send five automated questions to other users, you cannot send or receive personal messages. Viewing someone’s profile is possible, but not their photos.
You can upgrade your account to send and receive messages, view pictures, have a video date and use the What If? feature. This feature displays 30 additional matches that are not in your preferred list.
eHarmony is the best in terms of upgrade value. It is priced affordably, the matchmaking system is among the best on any dating site, as well as access to millions of other members.
The Winner:
Match and eHarmony are almost tied when it comes down to upgrading quality. Both Match and eHarmony give you the opportunity to communicate with other users, which is what you most desire. eHarmony has a slight edge because you have less chance of messaging a user who isn’t registered but may not be able to respond to your message.
EHarmony vs Match: Which is Better?
Both Match and eHarmony offer reliable, trustworthy premium dating services that can help you find your life partner. eHarmony has a better matchmaking system, and the results (600,000.+ marriages) speak for itself.
Both sites let you sign up and browse free of charge. Next, you will need to choose which site is best for you and create an Account.
I wish you all the best, no matter what you do!
Get a detailed review:
- Review of Match.com
- eHarmony review
What are the Alternatives?
Both eHarmony and Match are reliable, well-known dating sites. There are many other options.
- Elite Singles
Elite Singles is a niche dating website for young professionals who are looking for a partner with ambition and beauty. Elite Singles is a site for educated singles who don’t have the time to go to bars or look for what they want. 80% of its members hold a university degree. It’s a great alternative to Match or eHarmony. Read Elite Singles review.
- Lots of Fish
Plenty of Fish (POF), is an online dating site that has been around for a long time. It is aimed at those looking for long-term relationships as well as those looking for something more short-term. There are many features. It’s also free to send and get messages. It does not have as advanced a matchmaking system than eHarmony and is plagued with time-wasters as well as fake profiles. It’s worth looking at if you have a limited budget and are interested in trying out a few dating sites. Check out the POF.com review.
- OkCupid
OkCupid, like POF is completely free to send and get messages. People who are looking for long-term relationships will find it appealing. Many users spend the time to fill out their profiles. OkCupid is known for offering a safe online dating environment for people who don’t want to be hassled. OkCupid is a highly-rated dating app. It has very few fake profiles, time-wasters and appeals to the LGBTQ+ community. Check out the OkCupid review.